The Reluctant Landlord: How They’re Changing the Market

The rental market is shifting, and a new type of property owner is driving the change: the reluctant landlord. These are individuals who didn’t originally set out to be landlords but found themselves in the role due to circumstances like inheriting property, job relocations, or an inability to sell their home at the desired price. While their entry into real estate investing may be unplanned, their impact on the market is undeniable.

Who Are Reluctant Landlords?

A reluctant landlord is typically someone who:

• Inherits a property and decides to rent it out instead of selling.

• Moves to a new home but keeps the old one as a rental due to market conditions.

• Faces difficulty selling a property and opts for rental income instead.

• Buys a home with a partner but later experiences a breakup, leading to a rental scenario.

• Encounters economic uncertainty and sees renting as a safer financial option.

Unlike intentional real estate investors, reluctant landlords often have limited property management experience, which can lead to challenges—but also opportunities.

How Reluctant Landlords Are Shaping the Market

1. Increasing Rental Supply in Unlikely Places

Many reluctant landlords own single-family homes in suburban or residential areas that weren’t traditionally rental-heavy. This trend is expanding rental options outside of typical multifamily-dominated neighborhoods, offering renters more choices.

2. Raising Standards for Rental Properties

Because many reluctant landlords are renting out their former primary residences, tenants often benefit from well-maintained homes with higher-end finishes, better appliances, and improved landscaping compared to traditional rental stock.

3. Creating More “Mom-and-Pop” Landlords

Instead of large corporations dominating the rental space, reluctant landlords contribute to a growing segment of small-scale, independent property owners who personally manage their rentals. This can create a more personal touch in landlord-tenant relationships but also potential inconsistencies in property management.

4. Affecting Home Prices and Sales Trends

As more homeowners choose to rent rather than sell, housing inventory tightens, which can drive up home prices. This trend is particularly noticeable in cities where demand for housing is high but affordability remains an issue.

Challenges Reluctant Landlords Face

• Property Management – Many lack experience in handling tenant issues, maintenance, and rent collection.

• Legal and Compliance Risks – Without proper knowledge of landlord-tenant laws, they may unknowingly violate housing regulations.

• Financial Uncertainty – Market fluctuations, unexpected repairs, or non-paying tenants can turn rental income into a financial strain.

• Emotional Attachment – Renting out a former home can be emotionally difficult, making it harder to enforce lease rules.

Tips for Reluctant Landlords to Succeed

1. Educate Yourself – Learn local landlord-tenant laws and best practices for property management.

2. Screen Tenants Thoroughly – A great tenant makes everything easier. Always check credit, income, and rental history.

3. Have a Solid Lease Agreement – Protect yourself legally with a well-written lease that clearly defines terms and expectations.

4. Budget for Unexpected Costs – Set aside funds for maintenance, vacancies, and other unexpected expenses.

5. Consider Hiring a Property Manager – If managing a rental is too overwhelming, a property management company can handle the day-to-day for you.

   
   

Bottom Line

Reluctant landlords may not have planned to enter the rental market, but their presence is shaping real estate in meaningful ways. Whether you’re a seasoned investor or just starting, understanding this growing segment of landlords can help you better navigate today’s housing market.

FAQ

Q: I’m new to renting—how do I price my property?A: Research comparable rentals in your area. Online tools like Zillow and Rentometer can help you find a competitive rate.

Q: What’s the biggest mistake reluctant landlords make?A: Many fail to screen tenants properly. A bad tenant can cost you more in damages and unpaid rent than a vacancy ever could.

Q: Should I form an LLC for my rental property?A: It depends on your risk tolerance and financial situation. An LLC can offer liability protection, but it also comes with legal and tax considerations.

Q: How do I handle late rent payments?A: Have a clear late-fee policy in your lease and enforce it consistently. If a tenant repeatedly pays late, consider eviction as a last resort.

Q: Is renting really worth it, or should I just sell?A: If you can cover your mortgage and expenses while generating positive cash flow, renting could be a strong long-term wealth-building strategy. However, if the stress outweighs the benefits, selling might be the better choice.

Learn The 5 Step Process Hundreds of Investors Have Used To Close Multifamily Deals In 90 Days With As Little As $18k Out Of Pocket.

LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST

🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!

You can also find us on Facebook, and YouTube. 

Join our Facebook Group here!

Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.

Here's how I can help: 

1. Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.

2. Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.  

—Justin Brennan