Why Multifamily Investors Are Ditching Flips for Long-Term Holds (And How to Profit From the Shift)

Something fundamental shifted in real estate investing over the past 18 months, and most people are just now catching on. The investors who made fortunes flipping properties in 2020-2022 are quietly pivoting to a completely different strategy—and it's not because flipping suddenly became unpopular. It's because the math broke.

According to recent investor sentiment data, 44% of

rs now identify primarily as rental property owners, up significantly from previous years, while flippers dropped to just 38%. This isn't a trend—it's a survival adaptation. With interest rates still hovering in the 6-7% range, insurance premiums climbing 20-40% in many markets, and construction costs elevated, the quick-flip model that worked beautifully three years ago now leaves investors underwater or barely breaking even.

For multifamily investors specifically, this shift creates a massive opportunity. While single-family flippers scramble to adapt, apartment building investors who understand how to underwrite for long-term holds in today's environment are quietly building wealth. The question isn't whether you should pivot to long-term multifamily holds—it's whether you understand how to make money doing it when margins are compressed and every expense line item keeps climbing.

1. Why the Flip Model Broke (And Why Multifamily Long-Term Holds Still Work)

Let's be honest about what killed house flipping: everything got expensive at once, and there's no single line item to blame.

The cost structure that changed:

• Hard money loans jumped from 8-9% to 11-13%

• Insurance premiums spiked 30-50% in most markets, 100%+ in Florida and Louisiana

• Materials costs remain 30-40% higher than 2020 levels

• Labor costs increased 20-25% and contractors are still backed up months

• Holding costs (taxes, utilities, security) keep climbing while properties sit

A flip that penciled in 2021 with 4 months holding time and $60K in renovation costs now takes 8 months and $85K—and that's if you don't hit surprises. Your profit margin that was $75K is now $18K, assuming you can even find a buyer willing to pay your target price.

Why multifamily long-term holds avoid this trap:

You're not racing the clock. A 32-unit apartment building doesn't care if renovations take 8 months instead of 4—you're collecting rent the entire time. Your residents are covering most of your holding costs while you execute the value-add plan.

More importantly, multifamily investors can underwrite for compressed margins and still win because you're playing a different game. A flip needs 15-20% profit margins to justify the risk and effort. A long-term multifamily hold can work at 7-9% cash-on-cash returns because you're also capturing:

• Principal paydown (forced savings)

• Appreciation over 5-10 years

• Tax benefits (depreciation, cost segregation)

• Equity capture through forced appreciation (unit renovations)

The margins might be tighter, but the returns compound over time instead of resetting to zero after each transaction.

2. The Real Costs Everyone's Underestimating (And How to Underwrite for Them)

If you're still using 2022 expense ratios to underwrite 2026 multifamily deals, you're setting yourself up for disaster. Three cost categories exploded and show no signs of retreating:

Insurance: The Silent Portfolio Killer

Property insurance has become one of the most unpredictable expenses in multifamily investing. Florida investors are seeing 150-200% premium increases. "Safe" markets like Texas and Georgia are still seeing 25-40% jumps. Even Midwest markets traditionally immune to insurance volatility are experiencing 15-20% annual increases.

Action item for multifamily investors: Get actual insurance quotes BEFORE going hard on a deal. That $120K annual insurance budget you modeled might actually be $185K, and that destroys your cash-on-cash return. Many investors are learning this after closing—don't be that person.

Call three insurance brokers who specialize in multifamily. Get quotes in writing. Build that number into your proforma, then add 10% buffer for year two and three increases.

Property Taxes: The Lagging Indicator

As property values climbed 30-50% in many markets from 2020-2023, assessors are just now catching up. Many multifamily properties are being reassessed at 25-35% higher valuations, and your tax bill follows proportionally.

The trap: You buy a 40-unit building where the seller paid $48K in annual property taxes. Twelve months after your purchase, you get reassessed at the new purchase price and now owe $67K annually. That's $1,583 more per month you didn't budget for.

Underwriting fix: Don't use the seller's old tax bill. Calculate property taxes based on your purchase price × local tax rate, or assume a 20% increase from current taxes if you're buying significantly above the last assessed value.

Maintenance & CapEx: The New Reality

HVAC systems that cost $5,500 per unit in 2020 now run $7,500-8,000. Roofs, parking lot resurfacing, plumbing—everything costs more, and lead times are longer.

Your old CapEx budget of $250/unit/year probably needs to be $350-400/unit now. On a 50-unit building, that's $5,000-7,500 more annually you need to reserve.

The discipline that separates pros from amateurs: Set aside actual CapEx reserves from day one. Not "I'll save money when cash flow is good"—literally transfer $350/unit/month into a separate capital reserves account. Future you will thank present you when that roof needs replacing and you have $140K sitting there instead of scrambling for a capital call.

3. Operational Efficiency: Where Multifamily Long-Term Holds Win Big

Here's the advantage most investors overlook: operational efficiency compounds over time with long-term holds in ways that flips can never capture.

Technology and Systems That Actually Pay Off:

Property management software, automated rent collection, digital maintenance requests, smart access systems—these all have upfront costs that make zero sense on a flip. Why spend $3,000 setting up property management software for a property you'll own for 6 months?

But on a long-term multifamily hold? That $3,000 investment in Buildium or AppFolio saves you 10-15 hours monthly in administrative work. Over 5 years, that's 600-900 hours of your time saved. At $100/hour effective rate, that's $60K-90K in value from a $3,000 investment.

Real efficiencies that matter:

• Online rent collection reduces late payments from 8-10% of residents to 2-3%

• Automated lease renewals with 60-day reminders increase retention from 65% to 78%

• Digital maintenance requests with photo uploads reduce back-and-forth and contractor trips

• Smart thermostats save 12-18% on utility costs in master-metered buildings

• LED retrofits pay back in 18-24 months then save $200-400/unit annually forever

None of these make sense on a flip. All of them are game-changers on long-term holds because the benefits compound annually.

Tenant Retention: The Most Undervalued Metric

Turnover costs you $2,000-4,000 per unit when you factor in lost rent during vacancy, cleaning, minor repairs, leasing costs, and admin time. On a 40-unit building with 35% annual turnover, that's $28K-56K annually burned on churn.

Increase retention from 65% to 80% and you save $18K-35K annually. How do you do that?

Retention strategies that work:

• Offer 60-day renewal notices with small rent increases (3-4%) instead of last-minute big jumps (8-10%)

• Respond to maintenance requests same-day, complete repairs within 48 hours

• Add small quality-of-life improvements annually (better lighting, package lockers, dog park)

• Communication that treats residents like customers, not annoyances

Long-term hold investors can invest in retention because they'll harvest those benefits for years. Flippers don't care because they won't own the property long enough for retention to matter.

4. The Markets Where Multifamily Long-Term Holds Still Pencil

Not every market works for long-term holds in today's compressed-margin environment. You need markets where operational expenses are manageable AND there's still a path to appreciation or solid cash flow.

Markets where multifamily long-term holds are working in 2026:

Tier 1: Midwest Cash Flow Markets Indianapolis, Columbus, Kansas City, Cincinnati, Louisville

• Purchase cap rates: 7-8%

• All-in costs predictable and below national average

• Insurance: $500-800/unit annually (vs. $1,500-2,500 in coastal markets)

• Property taxes: 1-1.5% of value (vs. 2-3% in Texas)

• Cash-on-cash returns: 8-11% achievable with moderate leverage

These markets won't double in value in 5 years, but they'll throw off consistent cash flow while you sleep, and you won't get killed by operating expenses.

Tier 2: Secondary Sunbelt Growth Markets Huntsville, Greenville SC, Knoxville, Fort Myers, Boise

• Purchase cap rates: 5.5-6.5%

• Moderate appreciation potential (3-5% annually)

• Insurance: moderate but climbing

• Rent growth: 4-6% annually

• Cash-on-cash returns: 6-9% with opportunity for forced appreciation

The sweet spot: enough cash flow to cover holding costs, enough growth to build equity over time.

Tier 3: Tertiary Markets Seeing Population Influx Fargo, Sioux Falls, Green Bay, Macon GA, Tyler TX

• Purchase cap rates: 6.5-8%

• Lower competition from institutional capital

• Operating costs very manageable

• Population growth from remote workers and retirees

• Cash-on-cash returns: 7-10%

These markets fly under the radar, which is exactly why they work. You're not competing with Blackstone for deals.

Markets to avoid for long-term holds in 2026:

• Anywhere insurance is 2x the national average and climbing (coastal Florida, Louisiana)

• Markets where new construction pipeline exceeds population growth (Phoenix, Austin proper, parts of Dallas)

• Markets losing population or major employers (some California markets, older Rust Belt cities)

5. How to Structure Multifamily Deals for Long-Term Success When Margins Are Tight

When profit margins are compressed, deal structure matters more than ever. The difference between a deal that works and one that bleeds you dry often comes down to how you finance it and what terms you negotiate.

Debt Strategy for Long-Term Holds:

Forget bridge debt unless you have a clear 12-18 month path to refinance. In today's market, agency debt (Freddie Mac/Fannie Mae) is your friend if you're planning a true long-term hold.

Why agency debt works:

• 30-year amortization vs. 25-year on bank debt (lower monthly payment)

• Non-recourse (your personal assets aren't on the line)

• Fixed rates available (lock in your costs for 5-10 years)

• Prepayment penalties can be structured/defeased if needed

Yes, rates are 6.5-7.5% right now. But if you're holding 7-10 years, you want stability over chasing the lowest rate on floating debt that could spike.

For smaller deals (under $2M): Local banks and credit unions offering 25-year amortization at 7-8% with reasonable prepayment terms. Build relationships—these lenders often have better terms for repeat borrowers.

Cash Flow Buffers That Save Deals:

Underwrite conservatively with these buffers built in:

• Operating expense ratio: 50% of gross rents (don't believe seller proformas showing 38%)

• Vacancy: 8-10% (even in "hot" markets—better to be pleasantly surprised)

• CapEx: $350-400/unit annually (not negotiable)

• Management: 8-10% of collected rents if you're using third-party PM

Run your numbers at these ratios. If the deal doesn't work, it doesn't work. Better to pass than convince yourself you'll "operate more efficiently" than everyone else. You won't.

Value-Add Timing:

Don't try to renovate 50% of units in year one. Spread your value-add plan over 24-36 months:

• Year 1: Renovate 20% of units as they turn (natural vacancy)

• Year 2: Push rent increases on renovated units, renovate another 25%

• Year 3: Complete final 30%, stabilize at new rent levels

This approach maintains cash flow throughout the renovation period instead of crushing it all at once.

6. Tax Strategy: The Long-Term Hold Advantage Nobody Talks About

Here's where long-term multifamily holds destroy flipping financially: tax treatment.

Flip a property and pay ordinary income tax rates (up to 37% federal) on your profit. Hold a multifamily property long-term and your effective tax rate on cash flow can be near zero for years thanks to depreciation.

Real example: 40-unit building generates $80K annual cash flow. But on paper you show a "loss" of $45K thanks to depreciation. You pay zero tax on that $80K. Over 10 years, that's $800K in tax-free cash flow while building equity.

Add cost segregation (accelerating depreciation on certain components) and you can create even larger paper losses that offset other income.

The 1031 exchange advantage:

Flippers can 1031 exchange but rarely do because they need the cash to fund the next flip. Long-term hold investors can 1031 repeatedly, deferring capital gains taxes indefinitely while scaling up.

Buy a $2M property, hold 7 years, sell for $2.8M. 1031 into a $4M property. Hold 7 years, sell for $5.5M. 1031 into an $8M property. You've gone from $2M to $8M in assets without ever paying capital gains tax.

This compounds wealth in ways flipping can't touch.

Investor Takeaway

The pivot from flipping to long-term multifamily holds isn't just a trend—it's a rational response to a market where compressed margins killed the quick-flip model but long-term fundamentals remain strong.

Multifamily investors who understand how to underwrite for today's higher operating costs, structure deals for sustainability, and capture the compounding benefits of operational efficiency, tax advantages, and equity growth will build serious wealth over the next 5-10 years. Those waiting for conditions to "get better" will watch from the sidelines while operators who adapted early scale their portfolios.

The key differences between investors who thrive in this environment and those who struggle:

Thriving investors: Underwrite conservatively with 50% expense ratios and real insurance quotes. They finance with long-term debt, build actual CapEx reserves, invest in systems that improve operations, focus on tenant retention, and play the long game knowing that wealth compounds.

Struggling investors: Still using 2021 expense assumptions. They maximize leverage with short-term bridge debt, skip CapEx reserves to boost cash flow on paper, treat residents like transactions, and constantly look for the exit instead of building sustainable operations.

The market doesn't care which type you are—but your results will clearly show it.

Long-term multifamily holds work in 2026 if you understand the new rules: higher costs are permanent, margins are compressed but sufficient, operational excellence matters more than ever, and patient capital wins. Structure your deals accordingly and you'll build wealth while everyone else debates when to jump back in.

Learn The 5 Step Process Hundreds of Investors Have Used To Close Multifamily Deals In 90 Days With As Little As $18k Out Of Pocket.

LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST

🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!

You can also find us on Facebook, and YouTube. 

Join our Facebook Group here!

Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.

Here's how I can help: 

1. Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.

2. Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.  

—Justin Brennan