Why Smart Multifamily Investors Are Ditching Flips and Doubling Down on Rentals Right Now

Here's what's happening in the trenches: investors who spent the last decade making bank on fix-and-flips are quietly shifting their entire strategy. They're buying fewer properties, holding longer, and focusing on cash flow instead of quick exits. And it's not because flipping suddenly got boring.

The math has fundamentally changed. Between financing costs that haven't budged much from their peaks, insurance premiums that seem to climb every renewal cycle, and buyers who are still sitting on the sidelines, the traditional flip model is leaving a lot of investors with properties they can't sell at the numbers they need. Meanwhile, rental demand remains strong, rents keep climbing in most markets, and patient investors are building actual wealth instead of chasing deal after deal.

If you're wondering whether to pivot your multifamily strategy from transactional plays to long-term holds, here's what the current market is telling us—and how to adapt without getting crushed by the transition.

1. The Flip Math Broke (And Might Stay Broken)

Let's be honest about what killed the golden age of flipping: it's not just one thing, it's the compounding effect of everything getting expensive at once.

The numbers that changed:

• Hard money and bridge loans that used to cost 8-9% now run 10-12% or higher

• Renovation costs are up 30-40% since 2020 in most markets, and good contractors are booked months out

• Holding costs (insurance, taxes, utilities) keep climbing while your property sits

• Exit buyers are financing at 6.5-7% rates, which kills their purchasing power

Real example: A 12-unit value-add deal in a solid secondary market might have worked beautifully in 2019 with 4% agency debt. Buy at a 6 cap, renovate units, bump rents, refinance or sell at a 5 cap. Today? You're borrowing at 7%+, your renovation budget just increased 35%, and if you want to sell, buyers are underwriting at 6.5-7% caps because their debt costs are higher too.

The profit margin that used to be 6-8 months of work and a healthy six-figure payday is now 14 months of headaches and breaking even—or worse.

The pivot: Investors who are winning right now bought that same 12-unit property with a 5-7 year hold in mind. They're doing the value-add work, yes, but they're not banking on a sale. They're banking on stabilized cash flow and letting time work in their favor.

2. Rental Fundamentals Are Actually Solid (Despite What CNBC Says)

While everyone's focused on doom-and-gloom headlines, rental housing quietly keeps performing. Multifamily vacancy rates nationally are hovering around 6-7%—not crisis levels—and rent growth, while slower than the 2021-2022 boom, is still positive in most markets.

What's driving demand:

• Homeownership is out of reach for a growing portion of Americans (median home price hit $420K+ in 2024, and hasn't dropped much)

• First-time buyers are getting older—now averaging 35-38 years old instead of 30

• Immigration continues to drive population growth in key metro areas

• Younger millennials and Gen Z are prioritizing flexibility over ownership

The opportunity: Multifamily investors with quality B and C+ properties in job-growth markets are seeing consistent demand. You're not going to get 15% annual rent increases like 2021, but 3-5% annual growth with 95%+ occupancy is very achievable—and that's enough to build serious wealth over time.

3. The Hidden Costs Everyone's Underestimating

If you're still underwriting deals with 2019 expense assumptions, you're setting yourself up for disaster. Three cost categories have exploded and show no signs of retreating:

Insurance (The Silent Killer): Property insurance has become one of the biggest wildcards in multifamily investing. Markets like Florida, Texas, and Louisiana have seen 100-200% increases in premiums over the past three years. Even "safe" markets are seeing 20-40% bumps.

Action item: Get insurance quotes BEFORE you go hard on a deal. I'm serious—make it part of your initial underwriting. That $80K annual insurance budget you penciled in might actually be $140K, and that destroys your cash-on-cash return.

Property taxes creeping up: As home values have climbed, so have assessments. Many markets are re-assessing properties at 20-30% higher valuations, and your tax bill follows. Don't assume last year's taxes apply to your pro forma.

Maintenance and CapEx inflation: HVAC systems that cost $4,500 per unit in 2020 now run $6,500-7,000. Roofs, parking lot resurfacing, plumbing—everything costs more. Your old CapEx budget of $250/unit/year probably needs to be $350-400/unit now.

Strategy shift: Build 15-20% cushion into your operating expense projections. Yes, this makes fewer deals pencil. That's the point. Better to pass on mediocre deals than get stuck in a property bleeding cash because you were optimistic on costs.

4. Debt Strategy Matters More Than Ever

In a low-rate environment, debt strategy was almost an afterthought. Get the cheapest money you can, lever up, rinse, repeat. Today? Your debt structure can make or break your entire investment thesis.

What's working now:

Agency debt for the patient investor: Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae loans are back in play with 30-year amortization, though rates are still in the 6-7% range depending on leverage and property quality. If you're planning to hold 7-10 years, this is your friend. Yes, you'll deal with prepayment penalties, but you get stability.

Assumable loans are gold: If you're buying a property with an existing agency loan at 3.5-4.5%, that assumption can be worth hundreds of thousands in value. Don't overlook this.

Bridge debt only if you have a clear path: Bridge loans still have their place for true value-add situations where you can stabilize quickly (12-18 months) and refinance into permanent debt. But don't kid yourself about timeline—things take longer than you think, and every extra month at 11% interest rate hurts.

Cash buyers are winning deals: Investors coming in with all-cash or 50%+ down are getting seller concessions and better pricing because they close fast and clean. If you have the capital, this is a meaningful advantage.

5. Where the Smart Money Is Actually Deploying

Not all multifamily markets are created equal right now. Some are overbuilt with new luxury construction competing for the same renters. Others have steady demand, limited new supply, and healthy fundamentals.

Markets showing strength:

• Sunbelt metros with continued job growth: Nashville, Raleigh, Charlotte, Greenville (SC)

• Affordable Midwest markets: Columbus, Indianapolis, Kansas City, Des Moines

• Tertiary markets within primary MSAs—think suburbs 30-40 minutes from major cities where people moved during COVID and aren't leaving

What to avoid:

• Markets with massive new construction pipelines (Phoenix, Austin, parts of Dallas have thousands of units delivering)

• Cities losing population or major employers

• Markets where your basis would put you in the top 10% of rents (you're betting on appreciation, not cash flow)

The filter: Look for markets with rent-to-income ratios that still make sense (rents under 30% of median household income), job diversity, and where new construction is limited by geography or regulation.

6. The Rental Strategy That's Quietly Outperforming

Here's a trend that's not getting enough attention: workforce housing—that B and C+ space serving renters making $40K-75K annually—is dramatically outperforming luxury product in many markets.

Why it works:

• Your resident pool is massive (this is median American income)

• Limited new competition (developers chase luxury because the margins are better on paper)

• Strong rent growth (these renters have been priced out of homeownership and need quality housing)

• More forgiving underwriting (lower rents mean lower renovation costs to get units rent-ready)

Real example: A 1980s-era 48-unit garden-style property in a secondary market, rents at $950-1,100/month. Light cosmetic updates, professional management, solid location near jobs. These properties are generating 8-10% cash-on-cash returns with 95%+ occupancy while new luxury construction down the street sits at 78% occupied.

The catch: You need to actually manage well. Workforce housing tenants require responsive maintenance, fair treatment, and properties that are safe and functional. Cut corners, and you'll have turnover and headaches. Do it right, and you build a cash-flowing machine.

Investor Takeaway

The real estate investment landscape has fundamentally shifted, and investors clinging to 2019 strategies are getting left behind. The opportunity hasn't disappeared—it's just moved. Today's winning play in multifamily is less about quick flips and aggressive leverage, and more about finding solid properties in good markets, financing them intelligently, managing conservatively, and letting compounding work over 5-10 years.

Yes, cash-on-cash returns might be 7-9% instead of 15%. But those returns are real, they're stable, and they're building equity while you sleep. The investors making money right now aren't the ones chasing the sexiest deals or the highest leverage—they're the ones running honest numbers, building in cushions for higher costs, and playing the long game.

This market is separating hobbyists from professionals. If you're willing to underwrite conservatively, manage actively, and think in years instead of quarters, there's real money to be made in multifamily rentals right now.

Learn The 5 Step Process Hundreds of Investors Have Used To Close Multifamily Deals In 90 Days With As Little As $18k Out Of Pocket.

LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST

🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!

You can also find us on Facebook, and YouTube. 

Join our Facebook Group here!

Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.

Here's how I can help: 

1. Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.

2. Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.  

—Justin Brennan