The Decision Nobody Talks About: Paying Off vs. Leveraging When Rates Are 6.5%

You've built something. Maybe it's three properties. Maybe it's ten.

Monthly rents come in. Mortgages go out. You're breaking even or barely cash flowing.

Then someone asks you the question that keeps you up at night: "Why don't you just pay off the loan?"

And you realize you don't have a good answer.

THE MATH LOOKED DIFFERENT WHEN RATES WERE 3%

Five years ago, this was easy.

Buy property at 3% interest. Rent covers mortgage + operating costs + profit. Refinance when rates drop (they always do). Repeat.

That was the BRRRR strategy everyone worshipped. Leverage was the superpower.

Then 2022 happened.

Rates jumped to 6.5%. Suddenly the same property that cashflowed at 3% breaks even or goes negative at 6.5%.

Now you're sitting on a property with $250K mortgage at 6.5% interest. Annual payment: $18K.

Over 30 years? You'll pay $289K just in interest.

That number haunts you.

THE LIQUIDITY TRAP NOBODY WARNS ABOUT

Here's what actually happens when you keep leveraging in this environment:

You own three properties. None cash flow strongly. Two break even. One runs $200/month negative.

Suddenly tenant A's HVAC dies. $6K repair.

Tenant B stops paying. $1,500/month income gone for 3 months while you evict.

Tenant C's roof leaks. $8K fix.

You started the year thinking "I have $50K in reserves."

Six months later? $12K left.

You're not sleeping well.

Your spouse starts asking when you'll "just pay off one property so we have breathing room."

And the worst part? You're right.

You're cash-negative overall. Reserves draining. You're essentially working for free to build

equity while bleeding money on maintenance and vacancies.

THE LOCK-IN EFFECT NOBODY MENTIONS

Here's the decision that actually matters:

Option A: Keep the mortgage. Wait for rates to drop. Refinance then.

Option B: Pay it off now. Immediately free up $1,500/month.

If you have $250K sitting somewhere (stocks, savings, another business), paying off the mortgage instantly changes your life.

$1,500/month × 12 months = $18K annual cash flow that's actually liquid.

For the first time, you're not bleeding. You're breathing.

And here's the thing nobody says out loud: You can always refinance and redeploy if rates drop. But you can't un-bleed money you already spent on maintenance and vacancy losses.

The locked-in 6.5% rate? You're already paying it anyway. The question isn't "Will rates drop?" The question is "Can I survive the present while waiting for the future?"

WHERE GEOGRAPHY MATTERS (AND YOUR ACCOUNTANT WON'T TELL YOU)

A $250K property in Texas? Maybe $1,400/month PITI, taxes stay reasonable. Break even or slight positive.

Same property in California? Property taxes double. Insurance climbed 30%. Now you're $300/month negative.

Same loan. Different markets. Completely different decisions.

I know investors in San Francisco who paid off rentals not because they suddenly got rich, but because carrying costs + taxes + insurance made cash flow impossible. They freed up $1,800/month by paying off.

Same investors in Austin? Holding the mortgage because taxes are low and rent growth is realistic.

One data point doesn't work across geographies. Your accountant should tell you this. Most don't.

THE W-2 INCOME REALITY

Here's what I've noticed separating investors who thrive from ones who struggle:

The thriving ones have W-2 income they can deploy strategically.

Bonus hits in January? Drop $30K toward mortgage principal.

Tax refund in March? Same thing.

Not rushing to buy the next property. Just methodically de-leveraging while maintaining optionality.

They're saying to themselves: "I'll pay down 30-40% of this mortgage, keep my liquidity intact, and when rates drop, I'll refinance and have equity to redeploy or massive monthly cash flow to capture new deals."

The struggling ones have W-2 income they're already thin on. They can't afford to pay down debt. They're using reserves just to survive month-to-month.

Those investors shouldn't be buying more. They should be de-leveraging.

THE STOCK MARKET ARGUMENT (AND WHY IT'S ACTUALLY STUPID RIGHT NOW)

Someone will show you this: "S&P 500 returns 10% annually. Your mortgage is 6.5%. Invest the difference!"

And mathematically? They're right.

Over 21 years, that extra $250/month in an S&P fund grows to $137K versus paying down the mortgage.

But that assumes:

• You have $250/month extra (you don't, you're breaking even)

• The S&P returns 10% for 21 years straight (nice story)

• You don't panic-sell in the next bear market (you will)

• Your real estate doesn't have emergency maintenance (it will)

The Nvidia example is great if you bought at $50/share. Less great if you bought at $600/share.

Real wealth gets built two ways:

1. Boring consistency (paying down debt, capturing cash flow when available)

2. Optionality (staying liquid enough to move when opportunities appear)

Leverage feels like both. It's actually neither when rates are 6.5%.

THE ACTUAL DECISION FRAMEWORK

Stop overthinking this. Answer these questions:

Question 1: Are you cash flowing?

If yes (truly yes, not "breaking even"), keep the leverage and wait for rate drops.

If no, pay it off and sleep.

Question 2: How deep are your reserves?

If you have 12+ months of expenses in reserves, you can handle leverage stress. If it's 3-6 months? Pay it off.

Question 3: Can you survive the next recession?

Not "will you survive." Can you. If you need liquidity to weather a downturn, paying off rentals gives you that safety net.

Question 4: Do you have W-2 income you can deploy?

If yes, the best move is hybrid: Keep some leverage (optionality), pay down some debt (breathing room), stay liquid.

THE REAL ANSWER

Leverage works when rates are low and cash flow is strong.

So the real question isn't "Pay off or keep it?"

The real question is: "Can I operate from a position of strength or am I just managing stress?"

If you're managing stress, pay it off. Build reserves. Wait for the environment to shift.

If you're operating from strength, keep the leverage and deploy capital aggressively into the down markets.

Most investors overestimate which category they're in.

Learn The 5 Step Process Hundreds of Investors Have Used To Close Multifamily Deals In 90 Days With As Little As $18k Out Of Pocket.

LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST

🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!

You can also find us on Facebook, and YouTube. 

Join our Facebook Group here!

Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.

Here's how I can help: 

1. Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.

2. Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.  

—Justin Brennan