Capital Returned to CRE. Why Multifamily Got Left Behind.
Capital just came back to commercial real estate.
After the drought, money is flowing again. Bidding intensifying. Lenders competing. Deal activity climbing.
But multifamily didn't get invited.
For the first time in years, capital is choosing other sectors. And the pattern is clear: Investors looked at multifamily fundamentals and decided to go somewhere else.
THE CAPITAL RETURN NOBODY'S TALKING ABOUT
JLL's latest data shows CRE bidding hit its strongest monthly improvement in a year. July saw the second-highest number of unique bidders in five years.
Lending competition reached record levels. CMBS lenders, insurers, government agencies, debt funds—all competing for deals.
This should be your moment. Capital finally returning. Liquidity improving. Credit availability increasing.
Except it's not.
Because capital came back. It just didn't come back for apartments.
WHERE THE MONEY ACTUALLY WENT
Retail: Becoming the competitive target.
Why? Limited new supply. Owners enjoying attractive returns. Little incentive to sell. Renewed demand meeting constrained inventory.
Result: Bidding environment tightening. Prices climbing. Competition intensifying.
Investment outlook improving specifically because supply is controlled and owners won't sell.
Industrial: Remains investor favorite.
Manufacturing leasing up 27% year-over-year. E-commerce driving demand. Reshoring reshoring and reindustrialization changing supply chain economics.
Companies moving production closer to U.S. to reduce tariff exposure. That means industrial space = strategic asset right now.
Capital flooding in. Bidding competitive. Returns attractive.
D.C. Office: Emerging opportunity.
Values collapsed 50%+ from pandemic peaks. 22% vacancy. But that collapse created basis low enough to make renovation pencil.
Garfield Investments buying at 15-20% of replacement cost. Renovating into trophy space. Leasing up. Profit visible.
Capital recognizing opportunity in distressed asset. Moving in. Bidding intensifying.
Multifamily: Crickets.
WHY CAPITAL ABANDONED APARTMENTS
The math is simple.
Capital flows to fundamentals. When fundamentals weaken, capital leaves.
Multifamily fundamentals:
NOI growth collapsed to 1.8% (down from 3.4% prior year).
Revenue growth stalled. Expense growth cooled but didn't disappear. Net result: Margin compression.
Concessions still at 15.8% of stabilized units, averaging 11.1% discount. That's six weeks of free rent.
Rent growth flat to negative in most markets. Rents "up" in headlines but negative after concessions.
Stabilized vacancy rising (+34 bps in Q2) while headline vacancy improves. Translation: New construction absorbing demand. Existing properties losing renters.
Historic pipeline still being absorbed. Supply coming online for years.
The investor calculation:
"Multifamily generating 1.8% NOI growth. Industrial generating 27% leasing growth. D.C. office generating 15%+ returns on renovated assets. Retail generating stable returns on constrained supply. Why would I buy the sector with weakest fundamentals?"
They don't. So capital leaves.
THE CAPITAL FLOW SIGNAL NOBODY'S READING
Here's what's happening beneath the headlines:
Capital availability increased (credit easing, lenders competing).
But capital allocation diverged (went everywhere except multifamily).
That divergence is the real signal.
It means:
Capital isn't scarce. It's selective.
Multifamily isn't capital-constrained. It's return-constrained.
Operators can't blame capital markets. They have to blame their property fundamentals.
This is the moment of truth for multifamily investors.
For three years, operators blamed external factors: capital markets, COVID recovery, supply wave, rate environment.
Capital is back. Lending is loose. Credit is flowing.
And multifamily still can't compete for it.
That's not a capital market problem. That's a property problem.
THE DIVERGENCE IN THREE CHARTS
Chart 1: Bidding Competition
Retail: Bidding intensity rising (multiple offers, competitive tension)
Industrial: Strong bidding (reshoring demand)
D.C. Office: Emerging bidding (distressed basis attracting buyers)
Multifamily: Flat to declining (single offers, weak competition)
Chart 2: Capital Flow
Retail/Industrial/Office: Money moving in (capital seeking returns)
Multifamily: Money leaving (capital avoiding weakness)
Chart 3: Fundamental Trajectory
Retail: Limited supply + stable demand = improving returns
Industrial: Reshoring + e-commerce = growing demand
D.C. Office: Distressed basis + renovation upside = value creation
Multifamily: Historic supply + stalled rents + margin compression = deteriorating returns
WHAT OPERATORS ARE ACTUALLY DOING (NOT WHAT THEY'RE SAYING)
Smart multifamily operators aren't waiting for rents to recover.
They're repositioning.
Some moving to secondary markets with stronger rent growth (but still losing to industrial/retail on returns).
Some adding amenities to justify rent growth (but that's capex that compresses returns further).
Some selling to private equity at steep discounts (taking the loss, moving capital elsewhere).
The pattern: Multifamily operators treating their sector as a place to get out of, not a place to put money in.
That's the real signal.
WHY THIS MATTERS FOR YOUR PORTFOLIO
If you're sitting in multifamily waiting for capital to return:
Capital already returned. It just went somewhere else.
If you're waiting for rents to recover:
Rents aren't recovering fast enough to compete with returns in other sectors. Industrial up 27%. D.C. Office up 15%+. Multifamily up 1.8%.
If you're waiting for interest rates to drop:
Rates dropping doesn't help if cap rates are rising (which they are). Lower rates + rising cap rates = continued valuation compression.
The real question: Why are you holding multifamily when capital is flowing to sectors with better fundamentals?
WHERE SMART MONEY ACTUALLY MOVED
Move #1: Industrial Conversion
Multifamily operators acquiring industrial assets. Leasing to e-commerce companies. Getting 4-6% cap rates vs. 5%+ on multifamily with weaker fundamentals.
Move #2: Retail Repositioning
Acquiring retail with limited supply. Limited replacement cost. Owners not selling. Capital recognizing scarcity = returns.
Move #3: Office Value-Add
Buying distressed office at 15-20% of replacement cost. Renovating into mixed-use or luxury. Exiting multifamily to fund these plays.
Move #4: Non-Multifamily Diversification
Investors with multifamily exposure reducing concentration. Not because multifamily is terrible. Because it's no longer where marginal capital goes.
THE HONEST ASSESSMENT
Multifamily isn't broken. It's just not the best place for capital right now.
Industrial has secular tailwinds (reshoring, e-commerce, supply chain). Retail has structural scarcity (owner resistance, limited supply, capital constraints). D.C. Office has distressed basis creating value-add opportunity.
Multifamily has: Historic supply, stalled rents, compressed margins, competitive tension on renewals.
Capital isn't stupid. It follows returns. And right now, returns are better elsewhere.
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR YOUR REFINANCING WINDOW
If you have debt maturing in 2027-2028:
Lenders are loose. Credit is available. But capital allocation is selective.
Your multifamily property is competing for capital against industrial with 27% leasing growth and retail with structural scarcity.
Guess which one gets better terms?
The time to refinance is while rates are reasonable but before cap rates compress the valuation gap further.
Because right now, you can still refinance. But the terms keep getting worse.
THE REPOSITIONING PLAY NOBODY'S MAKING YET
The smartest move for multifamily operators right now:
Identify your weakest property. Sell it (yes, at a loss if needed). Redeploy capital to industrial/retail.
Take the tax loss. Buy better fundamentals. Accept lower cap rates on assets with stronger growth.
The property you're holding at a marginal 1.8% NOI growth is dragging your portfolio return down.
The industrial asset you could buy with those proceeds is contributing 4-6% yield + 2-3% growth.
Do the math over a 10-year hold.
The repositioning compounds.
THE BOTTOM LINE
Capital returned to CRE. Bidding intensified. Lending loosened.
But capital didn't return to multifamily. It went to sectors with better fundamentals, constrained supply, or distressed basis creating value-add opportunity.
If you're waiting for capital to choose multifamily again, you're waiting for returns to improve first.
And returns won't improve until operators stop holding marginal assets and capital stops abandoning the sector.
It's a vicious cycle. And the way out isn't waiting. It's repositioning.
Move your capital. Accept the loss. Buy better fundamentals elsewhere.
The operators who do that will outperform the ones who wait for multifamily to recover.
LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST
🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!
Join our Facebook Group here!
Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.
Here's how I can help:
Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.
Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.
—Justin Brennan
Comments