Tenant Reference Check Questions: 12 Must-Ask Landlord Screening Tips

Last week, I got a text from a fellow investor: "My new tenant seemed perfect on paper, but now I'm dealing with noise complaints and late rent. What did I miss?" The answer was simple—he'd skipped the most revealing part of tenant screening: actually talking to previous landlords.

Here's the reality about tenant reference check questions: most landlords either skip them entirely or ask the wrong ones. They get dazzled by good credit scores and steady income, then wonder why their "perfect" tenant is causing headaches three months later. The truth is, a five-minute conversation with a previous landlord can tell you more about a potential tenant than a stack of documents.

Smart investors know that landlord screening tips aren't just about protecting your property—they're about protecting your sanity, cash flow, and long-term wealth building. Because every problem tenant costs you more than just money; they cost you time, stress, and opportunities.

Why Tenant Reference Checks Are Your Secret Weapon

Before we dive into the specific questions, let's talk about why this step matters so much. Credit reports show you financial history, but they don't tell you if someone plays music at 2 AM or treats your property like a storage unit for broken appliances.

Previous landlords have lived through what you're about to experience. They know if this person respects lease terms, communicates problems appropriately, or disappears when rent is due. More importantly, they usually tell the truth—especially if you know how to ask.

The key is understanding that not all reference checks are created equal. You want to talk to the landlord before the current one, not just the current one. Why? Because current landlords might be overly enthusiastic about getting rid of a problem tenant.

12 Essential Tenant Reference Check Questions That Actually Work

Red Flags in Landlord Reference Responses

Immediate disqualifiers:

• Reluctance to provide details about the tenancy

• Overly enthusiastic responses that seem fake

• Reports of consistent late payments or lease violations

• Mentions of property damage, neighbor complaints, or communication issues

• Any suggestion they wouldn't rent to this person again

Proceed with caution signals:

• Lukewarm responses ("they were fine, I guess")

• Qualified recommendations ("they'd be okay for the right situation")

• Emphasis on positives while avoiding specific questions

• Short tenancies with vague explanations for moving

How to Make These Calls More Effective

Timing matters: Call during business hours when previous landlords have time to talk. Evening calls often get rushed responses.

Be professional but conversational: Introduce yourself, explain you're considering their former tenant, and ask if they have a few minutes to help.

Take detailed notes: Document exact responses, especially negative feedback. This protects you legally and helps with decision-making.

Verify the landlord: Make sure you're talking to the actual property owner or authorized manager, not a friend posing as a reference.

What If Previous Landlords Won't Talk?

Some landlords refuse to provide references due to legal concerns. Here's how to handle it:

Ask for written references: Some landlords will provide basic information in writing even if they won't discuss details over the phone.

Contact property management companies: Professional management companies often have policies allowing basic reference information.

Look for patterns: If multiple previous landlords won't provide references, that might be a red flag about the tenant's history.

Consider alternative verification: Court records, eviction databases, and professional tenant screening services can fill gaps.

Investor Takeaway

Effective tenant reference check questions are your insurance policy against costly tenant problems. The 20 minutes you spend on these calls can save you thousands in lost rent, property damage, and eviction costs. More importantly, they help you select tenants who'll respect your investment and contribute to your long-term wealth building.

Remember: good tenants appreciate thorough screening because they want professional landlords. If an applicant pressures you to skip references or seems annoyed by the process, that's valuable information too.

The goal isn't finding perfect tenants—they don't exist. It's finding responsible tenants who'll pay rent on time, follow lease terms, and treat your property with respect. These landlord screening tips help you identify exactly that type of tenant before you hand over the keys.

Learn The 5 Step Process Hundreds of Investors Have Used To Close Multifamily Deals In 90 Days With As Little As $18k Out Of Pocket.

LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST

🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!

You can also find us on Facebook, and YouTube. 

Join our Facebook Group here!

Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.

Here's how I can help: 

1. Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.

2. Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.  

—Justin Brennan