Stock Market vs Real Estate Investing: Why Multifamily Properties Beat Volatility in 2025

Last month, my neighbor Jim lost $40,000 in three days when tech stocks tanked. Meanwhile, I collected my monthly rent checks like clockwork—same amount, same day, rain or shine. Jim asked me over coffee: "How do you sleep at night knowing your money isn't 'working as hard' in real estate?"

Here's what I told him: My money works 24/7 without me watching CNBC.

The stock market vs real estate investing debate isn't new, but 2025 has made the choice clearer than ever. While stock investors are riding an emotional roller coaster of AI hype, inflation fears, and Fed speculation, multifamily investors are quietly building wealth through predictable cash flow and appreciating assets.

Don't get me wrong—I'm not anti-stock market. But when it comes to building real, sustainable wealth, multifamily properties consistently outperform volatile markets because they're based on fundamental human needs, not quarterly earnings projections or algorithmic trading.

Why This Comparison Matters More in 2025

Before we dive into the specifics, let's acknowledge the elephant in the room: both stocks and real estate can make you wealthy. But they do it in completely different ways, and 2025's economic environment heavily favors the real estate approach.

We're dealing with persistent inflation, interest rate uncertainty, and a generation of young adults who can't afford to buy homes. These conditions create a perfect storm for multifamily investing while making stock market timing even more treacherous.

The key insight: Stock market success requires predicting the future. Real estate success requires understanding the present.

Point 1: Predictable Cash Flow vs. Dividend Roulette

With multifamily properties, you know exactly how much money you'll make each month. Rent checks don't fluctuate with market sentiment, earnings reports, or whether Elon Musk tweets something controversial.

Compare this to dividend stocks, where companies can cut or eliminate payments at any time. During the 2020 pandemic, over 500 companies slashed their dividends. Meanwhile, essential housing demand remained rock solid.

Real example: A 20-unit apartment building generating $15,000 monthly in rent gives you $180,000 in annual cash flow. That number doesn't change because Tesla missed earnings or because the Fed raised rates. Your tenants still need somewhere to live.

Stock market reality: Even "safe" dividend stocks like AT&T have cut dividends by 50% in recent years. When companies face pressure, shareholder payments are usually the first thing to go.

The stability factor: Multifamily cash flow typically grows over time through rent increases that match or exceed inflation. Stock dividends can disappear overnight based on corporate decisions you have zero control over.

Point 2: Inflation Protection That Actually Works

Real estate is often called an inflation hedge, but multifamily properties are inflation fighters. When costs rise, you can raise rents. When materials get expensive, your property values increase accordingly.

Stocks, on the other hand, often get crushed during inflationary periods. Higher costs squeeze corporate margins, and investors flee to "safer" assets. The result? Your portfolio value drops just when you need inflation protection most.

How this plays out practically:

• Multifamily: If inflation runs 4%, you can typically raise rents 3-5%, maintaining or improving your real returns

• Stocks: During high inflation periods, stocks historically underperform as P/E ratios compress and earnings get squeezed

2025 example: With grocery prices up 20% over three years, tenants accept reasonable rent increases as normal cost of living adjustments. Meanwhile, consumer discretionary stocks struggle as people spend more on necessities and less on corporate products.

Point 3: Leverage Without Margin Calls

Here's where real estate gets really powerful: Banks will lend you 75-80% of a property's value at relatively low interest rates, and they can't demand that money back just because the market has a bad day.

Try that with stocks and you're playing with fire. Stock margin accounts can trigger margin calls that force you to sell at the worst possible times. Real estate leverage is patient—your mortgage payment stays the same whether your property is worth $2 million or $1.8 million

The math advantage:

• Real estate: Put down $500,000 on a $2.5M property. If it appreciates 5%, you make $125,000 on your $500,000 investment (25% return)

• Stocks: Put $500,000 in stocks with no leverage. A 5% gain gets you $25,000 (5% return)

Risk management difference:

• Real estate loans: Fixed payments, no margin calls, predictable terms

• Stock margin: Variable rates, margin calls, potential forced liquidation during market downturns

Point 4: Control and Value Creation Opportunities

With stocks, you're a passenger. With multifamily properties, you're the pilot. You can't call Apple and suggest they improve their profit margins, but you can absolutely improve your property's income and value.

This control factor is huge for wealth building because it means your returns aren't entirely dependent on market forces beyond your influence.

Value-add strategies you control:

• Renovate units to justify higher rents

• Improve operational efficiency to reduce expenses

• Add income streams (laundry, parking, storage)

• Implement energy-saving measures to reduce costs

• Better property management to reduce turnover

Stock market reality: Your Disney stock performs based on movie releases, theme park attendance, and streaming competition. You have zero input on any of these factors.

Example: I bought a 24-unit property for $2.1M, spent $150K on renovations, and increased rents by $200/month per unit. That $48,000 in additional annual income increased the property value by roughly $600,000 (at a 8% cap rate). Try creating $600K in value with your stock portfolio in 18 months.

Point 5: Tax Advantages That Compound Wealth

The tax code loves real estate investors. Depreciation allows you to deduct the property's cost over 27.5 years, often creating paper losses that shelter your cash flow from taxes.

Stock investors get no such benefits. Capital gains are capital gains, and dividend income is mostly taxable at ordinary income rates.

Real estate tax benefits:

• Depreciation deductions (often $50K+ annually on larger properties)

• Interest deduction on mortgages

• Cost segregation studies for accelerated depreciation

• 1031 exchanges to defer capital gains indefinitely

• Opportunity zones for additional tax benefits

  
  

Stock market taxes:

• Short-term gains taxed as ordinary income (up to 37%)

• Long-term gains taxed at 15-20% (still a real cost)

• Dividend income mostly taxed at ordinary rates

• No meaningful deductions or shelters

  
  

Wealth building impact: The tax savings from real estate can be reinvested into more properties, creating a compounding effect that's hard to match with after-tax stock returns.

Point 6: Market Timing vs. Time in Market

Stock market success often depends on timing—when you buy, when you sell, when you rebalance. Miss the best 10 days in any given year and your returns get decimated.

Real estate rewards patience over timing. I've never met a long-term multifamily investor who worried about whether they bought at exactly the right moment. The monthly cash flow and gradual appreciation make timing less critical.

Why this matters:

• Stocks: Perfect timing can make or break returns. Emotional decisions (buying high, selling low) destroy wealth

• Real estate: Consistent ownership over 5-10 years typically produces good returns regardless of entry timing

Behavioral advantage: It's much harder to panic-sell a building than to dump stocks during a market crash. This forced patience often leads to better long-term results.

The Multifamily Advantage in 2025's Environment

Current market conditions heavily favor multifamily investing:

Demographics: 25-34 year-olds are still living with parents at elevated levels, creating pent-up rental demand as they eventually move out.

Affordability crisis: With average mortgage payments 35% higher than average apartment rents, many would-be buyers remain renters longer.

Supply constraints: Multifamily construction starts are down 74% from 2021 peaks, while demand remains strong.

Interest rate environment: While higher rates hurt stock valuations, they also reduce new construction competition and keep potential homebuyers in rental properties.

Addressing the Common Objections

"But stocks are more liquid!" True, but liquidity can be a curse if it encourages emotional trading. Real estate's illiquidity forces better long-term decision making.

"Real estate requires active management!" So does successful stock investing if you want to beat index fund returns. Plus, property management companies handle day-to-day operations for 6-10% of gross rents.

"What about diversification?" You can diversify across markets, property types, and tenant demographics. Geographic diversification in real estate is often more meaningful than sector diversification in stocks.

"Stocks have higher returns!" Over very long periods, yes. But risk-adjusted returns after taxes and inflation? Real estate often wins, especially when you factor in leverage and tax benefits.

When Stocks Still Make Sense

I'm not suggesting you avoid stocks entirely. Here's when stocks make more sense:

• You have limited capital (under $100K) and can't access good real estate deals

• You want completely passive investing and are comfortable with volatility

• You're investing for very long time horizons (20+ years) in tax-advantaged accounts

• You lack the time or interest to learn real estate fundamentals

The hybrid approach: Many successful investors use both. Build your foundation with multifamily properties for cash flow and stability, then use excess cash flow to invest in stocks for additional growth.

Investor Takeaway

Stock market vs real estate investing isn't really about which asset class is "better"—it's about which approach matches your wealth-building goals and risk tolerance. But in 2025's environment, multifamily properties offer compelling advantages that are hard to ignore.

Multifamily investing provides predictable cash flow, inflation protection, tax advantages, and the ability to create value through your own actions. These benefits become even more attractive when stock markets are volatile and economic uncertainty is high.

The key insight: stock market success requires predicting an uncertain future, while multifamily success requires understanding fundamental human needs that don't change. People will always need somewhere to live, and they'll pay market rates for quality housing regardless of what happens to Tesla's stock price.

This doesn't mean real estate is risk-free or that everyone should abandon stocks. It means that for investors seeking wealth building through cash flow, tax advantages, and controlled appreciation, multifamily properties offer a more predictable path than trying to time volatile markets.

Remember: the goal isn't to get rich quick—it's to build sustainable wealth that compounds over time. Multifamily properties excel at this because they combine current income with long-term appreciation, all while providing tax benefits that enhance your overall returns.

Learn The 5 Step Process Hundreds of Investors Have Used To Close Multifamily Deals In 90 Days With As Little As $18k Out Of Pocket.

LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST

🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!

You can also find us on Facebook, and YouTube. 

Join our Facebook Group here!

Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.

Here's how I can help: 

1. Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.

2. Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.  

—Justin Brennan