Short-Term Rentals in 2026: The Math Finally Stopped Working for Most Hosts
- Justin Brennan
- 14 hours ago
- 4 min read
You list your property on Airbnb in 2019.
Book 22 nights the first month. Clear $3,200 profit. Think you cracked the code.
Fast forward to 2025. Same property. Better photos. Lower price. 12 nights booked. Profit? $847.
What changed?
Everything.
The short-term rental gold rush is over. The easy money left three years ago. What's left is a professional operator's game—and most hosts are playing with amateur tools.
Here's what the data actually says about 2026. And why most hosts are about to get destroyed.
Supply Exploded. Demand Didn't Keep Up.
In 2019, Airbnb had 6 million listings globally.
Today? Over 7.5 million. That's 25% more supply competing for the same travelers.
Your listing isn't competing with 10 other properties anymore. It's competing with 150. In some markets, 300+.
The math is simple: More listings. Same number of travelers. Lower occupancy. Lower rates. Lower profits.
Markets that were printing money in 2021—Gatlinburg, Scottsdale, Gulf Shores—are now saturated. Occupancy rates dropped 15-20% year-over-year. Hosts slashing prices 30-40% just to book.
Translation: If you're not in the top 10% of listings in your market, you're getting crushed.
Operating Costs Doubled. Revenue Stayed Flat.
Here's the killer:
Cleaning costs: Up 35% since 2021.
Insurance premiums: Up 40-60% (some states doubled).
Property taxes: Up 20-30% in hot STR markets.
Utilities: Up 25% (especially electric/gas).Maintenance: Up 30% (everything costs more now).
But your nightly rate? Flat or down in most markets.
Example:2021 Nashville property:
Average nightly rate: $210
Operating costs: $4,200/month
Profit: $2,800/month
Same property, 2025:
Average nightly rate: $185 (down 12%)
Operating costs: $6,100/month (up 45%)
Profit: $950/month (down 66%)
The squeeze is real. Revenue down. Costs up. Margin destroyed.
Most hosts haven't adjusted. They're still underwriting 2021 numbers. That's why they're bleeding cash.
Airbnb Changed the Algorithm—And Didn't Tell Anyone
Here's what Airbnb doesn't say:
The platform now heavily prioritizes Superhosts. If you're not a Superhost, your listing gets buried. Page 3. Page 4. Page 7.
Nobody scrolls that far.
Superhost requirements:
4.8+ star rating (one bad review tanks you)
90%+ response rate within an hour (impossible if you work full-time)
1% cancellation rate or less (one emergency cancellation = gone for 6 months)
10+ stays in last year (hard to hit if you're new or seasonal)
Miss one metric? You're invisible.
And here's the kicker: Airbnb can change these requirements anytime. No warning. No explanation. Just... changed.
Hosts call it "the algorithm lottery." Some weeks you're page 1. Some weeks you disappear. Zero control.
That's not a business model. That's praying the platform likes you.
Regulations Are Killing Markets Faster Than Hosts Can Exit
New York City just banned short-term rentals under 30 days (unless owner-occupied).
Result? 10,000+ listings vanished overnight. Hosts stuck with properties they can't rent. Can't sell (market flooded). Can't afford to hold.
Other cities cracking down in 2025:
San Diego: New permit caps + lottery system
Austin: Strict occupancy limits + neighbor complaints = immediate shutdown
Denver: New zoning restrictions + expensive licensing
Palm Springs: 30-night minimum rentals in residential zones
What this means: Markets that worked in 2023 are illegal in 2026. If you bought in the wrong city, you're holding a depreciating asset you can't monetize.
The Hosts Who Survive Do 3 Things Differently
Not everyone is losing. Some hosts are crushing it.
What separates winners from losers:
1. They Own Multiple Properties in Diversified Markets
Single-property hosts are sitting ducks. One regulation change. One bad review. One algorithm shift. Income gone.
Winners own 3-5+ properties across different cities. When Nashville slows down, their Asheville properties pick up slack. When regulations hit Austin, their Phoenix units keep cash flowing.
Risk diversification = survival.
2. They Built Direct Booking Engines
Airbnb takes 15-20% of every booking.
Smart hosts built their own websites. Captured guest emails. Built repeat booking systems. Now 30-40% of revenue comes direct—zero platform fees.
Example:Host with $120K annual revenue on Airbnb = $18K-24K in fees.
Same host with 40% direct booking = $7K-10K in fees saved.
That's $11K-14K straight to profit. Just by cutting out the middleman.
3. They Track Unit Economics Like a CFO
Amateurs track revenue. Pros track profit per available night.
Winners know:
Cost per booking (cleaning, supplies, platform fees)
Cost per occupied night (utilities, consumables, wear/tear)
True cash-on-cash return (after ALL expenses, including their time)
Most hosts think they're profitable. Then they run the real numbers. They're losing money.
Winners kill underperforming properties fast. Amateurs hold on hoping it gets better. It doesn't.
The Reality: Most Hosts Will Quit in 2026
Here's what the data shows:
41% of hosts made less money in 2025 than 2024.38% are "reconsidering" their STR strategy.22% plan to exit entirely in 2026.
Why?
Occupancy down
Costs up
Margins destroyed
Platform dependency
Regulatory risk
Time commitment unsustainable
The hosts who treated STRs as passive income are getting destroyed. The hosts who treat it as an operating business are winning.
The question isn't whether STRs work in 2026.
The question is: Are you good enough to compete?
Will It Be Worth It in 2026?
For most hosts? No.
If you're:
Running one property
Relying 100% on Airbnb
Not tracking true unit economics
Hoping occupancy "comes back"
Treating this as passive income
You're going to lose money. Sell now before your market gets saturated or regulated.
For professional operators? Absolutely.
If you're:
Diversified across multiple properties/markets
Building direct booking channels
Running lean operations with systemized cleaners/maintenance
Tracking profitability per unit, per night
Treating this like a real business
You'll print money while amateurs exit.
The gold rush is over. The professional era just started.
Which side are you on?
LIVE Q&A TRAINING WITH JUSTIN THIS WEEK! 6PM PST
🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!
Join our Facebook Group here!
Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.
Here's how I can help:
Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.
Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.
—Justin Brennan
