top of page

Navigating Property Insurance Costs for Investors

As the real estate market continues to evolve, property owners have encountered a notable surge in insurance premiums. This increase has sparked the need for a deeper comprehension of the underlying factors driving these changes and has become essential for real estate investors to navigate the dynamic and unpredictable market landscape.

Rise in Premiums: What's Behind It?

Rise in Premiums: What's Behind It?

The uptick in insurance premiums can be attributed to several influential factors that have reshaped the insurance market:

1. Impact of Extreme Weather Events

Regions prone to frequent extreme weather events and natural disasters, such as hurricanes, tornadoes, and wildfires, have placed significant pressure on insurance carriers. The increasing severity and frequency of these disasters have prompted carriers to reconsider their payout history, ultimately leading to widespread premium rate hikes.

2. Strain from Labor and Material Shortages

Persistent shortages of skilled labor and supply chain disruptions owing to COVID-19 have resulted in a notable surge in construction costs over the past four years. The need to retain skilled workers at higher wages has driven up project costs, while delayed production of construction materials due to supply chain disruptions has further inflated prices, ultimately impacting property repairs and leading to higher payouts for insurers.

3. Impact of Diminishing Buying Power

A steady escalation in inflation over the past four years has eroded the buying power of consumers across various sectors, including construction. This rising cost of essential goods and services has prompted construction workers to demand higher wages, perpetuating a cycle of increased costs. Coupled with supply chain issues, the dwindling value of the dollar has translated into insurers requiring more funds to cover property damage, thus necessitating increased premium rates.

Strategies to Stabilize Insurance Costs: Proactive Approaches

While realizing significant reductions in insurance costs without making exhaustive changes can be a challenge, property owners can adopt proactive measures to curb further escalations:

1. Annual Assessment and Creative Coverage Options

The practice of annually evaluating insurance options can deliver significant value. While price variances may be marginal, it is essential to explore potential benefits, policy structures, and included coverages. Additionally, considering innovative coverage options to offset heightened costs, facilitated by a knowledgeable insurance agent, ensures well-informed decision-making.

2. Emphasizing Property Maintenance

Prioritizing the maintenance of a property can significantly mitigate the likelihood of encountering costly damages, benefiting both insurance premiums and the longevity of the property. Articulating clear tenant maintenance responsibilities in the lease can ensure the timely reporting of hazards and expedited risk mitigation.

3. Mandating Renters Insurance

Incorporating a clause in the lease that mandates tenants to carry renters insurance is advantageous for both renters and property owners. With renters insurance in place, insurers can seek reimbursement through subrogation, ultimately reducing the payout amount on the property owner's policy and fostering rate stabilization over time.

Independent Brokers' Expertise

Engaging with independent insurance brokers specializing in residential investment properties offers distinct advantages. These brokers represent multiple insurance companies, enabling property owners to secure tailored and comprehensive coverage at competitive prices, specifically crafted to protect their assets.

Property Insurance Variances

Property Insurance Variances

When deliberating over the choices of property insurance, numerous factors and considerations come into play. The decision between replacement coverage and actual price value, the need for vacancy insurance, and the array of insurance policies tailored for diverse requirements necessitate a meticulous assessment.

If you want to read more about the types of property insurance, this blog post is for you.

Grappling with Making Claims: Balancing Act

While the purpose of insurance policies is safeguarding properties, exercising prudence with respect to claims is paramount. A saturation of claims in a condensed timeframe can potentially compromise future insurance acquisition ability, elevating the significance of judicious claim submissions.

Gauging the Coverage Necessity: Tailoring to Individual Needs

A discerning evaluation of individual situations and the requisite coverage as per the property type and investment strategy is indispensable. Partnering with brokers and deploying dedicated tools to procure comprehensive assessments help in ascertaining the optimal coverage needed.

Bottom Line

With the persistent surge in insurance premiums, real estate investors are urged to maintain an active approach in managing their coverage. Sustained communication with insurance agents, the implementation of sound risk management practices, and a comprehensive understanding of policy details are pivotal steps. Despite the challenges posed, an informed and proactive stance enables property owners to navigate the evolving insurance landscape with resilience and assurance.


What are the primary factors driving the surge in insurance premiums for real estate investments?

The surge in insurance premiums is primarily attributed to the increasing severity and frequency of extreme weather events, persistent labor and material shortages, and the escalating impact of inflation on buying power.

How can property owners proactively stabilize their insurance costs amid these shifts?

Property owners can adopt proactive measures, including annual insurance assessments, emphasis on property maintenance, the mandate for renters insurance, and leveraging independent insurance brokers' expertise, to curb further escalations in insurance costs.

What are the key considerations when selecting property insurance?

Key considerations when selecting property insurance include evaluating the choice between replacement coverage and actual price value, the need for vacancy insurance, and a comprehensive grasp of the wide array of insurance policies tailored to specific needs.

Considering Mentorship?

Justin Brennan mentorship

🙏🏼 Thanks for reading!

You can also find us on Facebook, and YouTube.

Join our Facebook Group here!

Click here to join our WhatsApp Community.

Here's how I can help: 

  1. Book a strategy call with Justin and his team to get "eureka moment" clarity about where you're at and where you want to go with real estate investing and plan.

  2. Get investing tools and learning by starting with The Multifamily Schooled Courses.  

—Justin Brennan

12 views0 comments


Justin Brennan

Trending Articles

bottom of page